Our local conservative contributor, tony8489, has asked me to post his views on the recent "You Lie!" controversy. As you may have heard, South Carolina Republican Joe Wilson screamed "You Lie" during President Obama's speech on health care. That statement has set off a firestorm of criticism and, also, support. Here is tony 8489's take, and he wanted me to let you all know that he offers equal time for other reader's rebuttles:
It all began when S.C. Republican Rep. Joe Wilson unexpectedly shouted"You lie!" during President Barack
Obama's Wednesday night address to Congress. The outburst was prompted when Mr. Obama asserted during his speech that illegal immigrants would not be covered under the president's health plan. The moment the speech ended, White House Chief of Staff
Rahm Emmunuel charged over to the Republicans-Reps. Ryan, Roy Blunt of Missouri, and Kevin McCarthy of California-demanding in a profanity-laced tirade that they force Mr.Wilson to apologize. The Congressman called the White House,
andasked Mr. Emmanuel to convey his apology to the president.
OnThursday, Mr. Obama accepted it.
The amount of hate, anger, and angst over this comment in the
mainstreet media and the loony left has been nothing short of astonishing. Each party is in charge of policing its fringe elements. Let's compare the
Huffington Post, arguably the Internet mouthpiece for the left, and
littlegreenfootballs.com, the Internet mouthpiece for the right. Spend a little time on both, and you will quickly discover little or no policing exists on either the
Huffington Post, or
Moveon.org. The postings that were on
HuffPo and
Moveon about Dick
Cheny's health problems were so shameful and disgusting they cannot be repeated here. When Ted Kennedy died, the postings on
lgf.com were respectful. The ones that were not were removed by the moderator, Charles Johnson. Why is this? Why is a certain level of hate tolerated, or even encouraged in the
MSM, and the political left, towards people who embrace conservatism as their expression of political belief?
*Anderson Cooper, the greatly respected CNN anchorman, called the "
tea party" participants "tea
baggers". He was alluding to an exotic sexual practice. Just the other day, Democratic Congresswomen, Carol Shea-Porter referred to Anti-Obama Care protesters as "tea
baggers." Pretty funny, right? We are reading a lot lately about "right wing rage." Funny how you never hear about "left wing rage." Could be that"left wing rage" is not alliterative as "right wing rage" is. Or it could be that dominant commentators think of left wing rage as mere righteous indignation.
*We are also hearing about "the angry white male"-the return of the angry white males". Funny how people get all race-and gender minded on you. There are many non-whites and non-males among the conservative protesters. And what about that terrible word"males"? Have the anti-conservatives ever heard of "men"? *They say "hate" is rearing it's head, and that President Obama and the Democrats are the victims of it.
Let's make a couple of predictions: I predict that the chairman of the Republican National Committee will never say, "I hate the Democrats and everything they stand for. This is a struggle of good and evil. And we are the "good". Howard Dean said that about the GOP. "I hate the Republicans and everything they stand for....." I predict that an editor of a conservative magazine will never write a piece called "The Case for Obama Hatred," beginning, "I hate President Obama". A New Republic editor did this, about Bush. And there is increasing worry about
assassination - that someone will take a shot, not just at the president, but at the first black president, which would be extra-catastrophic for the country. A few protesters have carried signs urging violence against Obama, or smacking of violence.
Let me make some more predictions: *I predict that a network talk-show will not show a video of President Obama giving a speech and put the following words on the screen: "SNIPERS WANTED." Craig
Kilborn did that to George W. Bush. *I predict that US senators will not joke about killing Obama. In 2006 Bill
Maher had a conversation with John Kerry. He asked Kerry what he'd gotten his wife for her birthday. Kerry said that he had treated her to a vacation in Vermont.
Maher said, "You could have went to New Hampshire and killed two birds with one stone." Kerry replied, "Or I could have gone to 1600 Pennsylvania and killed the real bird with one stone." This is the same Kerry who, in 1988, said, "Somebody told me the other day that the Secret Service has orders that if George Bush is shot, they're to shoot Quayle". Then he said, "There isn't any press here, is there?
*I predict that a New York official will not tell a graduating class about assassinating President Obama. In 2006 comptroller Alan
Hevesisaid to students at Queens College that Sen. Charles
Schumer, his fellow Democrat, would"put a bullet between the presidents eyes if he could get away with it". *I predict that no columnist for a leading European newspaper, and leading world newspaper, will write,"John Wilkes Booth, Lee Harvey Oswald, John
Hinckley Jr-where are you now that we need you?" Charlie
Brooker of the Guardian did that to George W. Bush.
*I predict that no major write will write a novel debating the morality of killing President Obama. Nicholson Baker did that to Bush, with "Checkpoint". *I predict that no filmmaker will make a "fictional documentary" that fantasizes-and I'm afraid that is the word-about murdering President Obama. Some Brits did that with "Death of a President" I have made very, very, safe predictions. If a CBS talk-show host pictured President Obama and said, SNIPERS WANTED, he would lose his job, of course. He would never work in the media again. I wonder what else would happen to him. I could go on, but hopefully you have heard enough. Here is my point. The type of thinking I have presented to you is in the mainstream of democratic thinking. All the way from the head of the
DNC down. We all know that each side has its share of kooks. But in this case, the inmates are running the asylum.
As a Republican, I am ashamed sometimes at the political sniping and remarks that are made to the opposition. Have a little class, and show some humility. But the examples I have offered are so outrageous, all they do is make me sad. There is a website called "
zombietime". and it's materials make for pretty rough, discomforting viewing. Here, the site had gathered many pictures taken at anti-Bush and anti-war rallies-and Obama rallies. They show signs and such screaming for the murder of Bush. They show pictures of Bush with a bullet through his head. They show depictions of Bush being guillotined. They show Bush being burned in effigy.Etc. etc.
"You lie", indeed.